Why wont Apple make a PDA?

[SFDMALEX]

Seeing how everybody is buing IPODs like hot cakes why wont Apple make a PDA with their own little OS?

Currently the market is all about portable devices, seeing apples success with the Ipod(Ipod Mini) it's a perfect time to make such a product.

Any ideas?

[pharzo]

Well they used to make one. The newton. It was great...i had one.

But really...with Palm OS and Pocket PC on the market...what could apple really offer?

[SFDMALEX]

Well they used to make one. The newton. It was great...i had one.

But really...with Palm OS and Pocket PC on the market...what could apple really offer?

What do they have to offer in any sector now? Nothing. But they are still selling.

As RC would say, pooftas and hairdressers would buy it over a Pocket PC just becase its Apple.

[AlienDB7]

It's actually a smart move on Apple's part. The PDA market isn't growing as fast as it used to. Eventually people will just buy "Smart phones" to replace their PDAs. Blackberry is a good example.

[RC45]

I used to have a Psion Handheld about 12+ years ago. The reason I chose it over the Newton at the time, because the Newton was "cool" - but about as useful as trying to use a fork as a spoon.

A keyborad is way easier to use than a stylus interface. Oh - and there ere way more applications for the Psion than the Newton.

Apple is really not into anything but fad products ;)

The reason I don't have a PDA or Handheld (even a Blackberry) these days - is because you are really no more productive with it than wihtout it.

People have generated this false sense of "productivity" simply because they are "always busy" and "always connected" - but seldom get more done that folks who sit down at there desk and churn out tasks ;)

Oh - and one more thing, why would I want some jackass calling me on a Saturday or Sunday when I am spnding quality time with the family :P heheh ;)

[pharzo]

I used to have a Psion Handheld about 12+ years ago. The reason I chose it over the Newton at the time, because the Newton was "cool" - but about as useful as trying to use a fork as a spoon.

A keyborad is way easier to use than a stylus interface. Oh - and there ere way more applications for the Psion than the Newton.



Yeah i had my Newton about 5 years ago though...

when it was launched i was about 7 so...i was productive enough without it :wink:

I actually prefered the interface to the psion...the psion was a bit bulky. With the whole fold out keyboard thing...kinda lame. I still think the newton had the best handwriting recognition software ever...better than the clie i had 3 years ago, and better than the ipaq i have now. I can understand the thing about applications though...but by the time i got mine, it had this really massive cult following, so there were tons of apps for it.

The reason I don't have a PDA or Handheld (even a Blackberry) these days - is because you are really no more productive with it than wihtout it.

PDA's are usefull for taking notes in class, reading the news, and browsing the net when nothing else is available (coffee shop). It's really dumb as an appointment book or to store contacts though

[SFDMALEX]

/\/\/\Well I have a Clie which I use for games whilst on the subway, and music...

[RC45]

^^^ I use the default Bejeweled game on my cell phone when I am in the crapper... :)

I can understand the thing about applications though...but by the time i got mine, it had this really massive cult following, so there were tons of apps for it.


My dad used his Psion for flight planning in the cockpit for the longest time.

[antonioledesma]

^^^ I use the default Bejeweled game on my cell phone when I am in the crapper... :)

did we really needed to know that?? :P

I have a clie, and I used to be more productive at school...playing games during lectures, conferences, etc.

but now that I don't have that many things to do, my cellphone does the right thing

[ae86_16v]

It's actually a smart move on Apple's part. The PDA market isn't growing as fast as it used to. Eventually people will just buy "Smart phones" to replace their PDAs. Blackberry is a good example.

Steve Jobs' been quoted to say exactly that. He thinks as devices become more and more intergrated the PDAs will eventually see their demise.

And that's exactly right, if you look at the "pure" PDA market it has been slowing down quite significantly.

[antonioledesma]

pda's as we know them will change (omfg!! I'm really smart :mrgreen: ), because no one wants to carry a pda and cellphone. And some years ago ppl had in their pockets pda's with no mp3, cells, and mp3 players.
I would pay for a small device that is a pda, cell, mp3 player, digital camera, and x-ray device :mrgreen:

[pharzo]

I would pay for a small device that is a pda, cell, mp3 player, digital camera, and x-ray device

Yes, but you inherently compromise certain features. I would rather have a great cellphone, that is small, with great battery life and a powerful antenna, but with no camera. Same goes for camera's and mp3 players. In my mind all the seperate devices are much better than if you make a "one size fits all" kinda device

It's like a swiss army knife. Sure it has a pen, corkscrew, screwdriver, saw, scissors, pliers, and that weird hook thing that has no use. But i'd still rather use a real pen, normal size corkscrew, a big saw, proper pliers...and a really big hook :P

[antonioledesma]

of course I understand that, but I don't like carrying my camera, cell, mp3, etc.
you can have your swiss army knife with you, but you can still have a decent set of tools in your house or car.
It's for daily use. Why go to the tool shed or garage, look for the proper tool, carry it to... you know :D . It's better to only reach for your swissknife, and the job is done

even if I had a multi-purpouse cell-mp3-gps-digicam-videocam-radio fm-compass-anything you want thing; I still would have my $700 usd slr digital camera, a decent $500 usd video cam, etc :mrgreen:
you can have the little boy's toy and the big boy's toy

[ae86_16v]

Yeah right now, what I really want would be a phone the size of Motorola's V3 with a 2 or even 3 MP Camera. I like all the features in the V3. Maybe make it a bit more customizable.

[Toronto]

apple are working on new cellphones

[SFDMALEX]

Im sure they'll make tons of money off of that./\/\/\

[Toronto]

I hope you are being serious. cell phones cost about the same as a PDA (the good ones) and is a bigger market then PDA's... and if motorola is backing them they must have somthing going their way :D

[ae86_16v]

Yeah, the iTunes phone. Remember 4 or 5 years ago they had the V70. . . that was a collaboration between Motorola and Apple.

[SFDMALEX]

I hope you are being serious. cell phones cost about the same as a PDA (the good ones) and is a bigger market then PDA's... and if motorola is backing them they must have somthing going their way :D

I am serious man :lol: This thread is serious :wink:

[RC45]

You can't do this with a PDA... ;)

http://www.jokaroo.com/funnyvideos/hiddenwebcam.html