PDA

View Full Version : Harry Potter anyone? (Spoilers inside...beware!)


Apac102
07-25-2005, 12:39 PM
I finished the new Harry Potter and let me tell you it was quite depressing. If you are a harry potter fan then you will agree that the death of dumbledore is monumentously a let down. And to top it off, harry debates wether or not he will come back to Hogwarts?! I have been recently comparing this the Empire Strikes Back from Star Wars. As nerdy as Star Wars and Harry Potter may sound in the same sentence from a 20 year old :? , it still is heartbreaking to have the series end on a note like this. Now We have to wait who knows how long for the next book to come out. I just finished yesterday and now Im hoping for the new one to come out next week! Its killing me.

evoWalo
07-25-2005, 12:42 PM
JK had to Kill Dumbledor. The original actor's dead and was replaced by Sir Michael Gambo who appeared as the "celebrity in the reasonably priced car" on BBC Top Gear last December 8, 2002.

yg60m
07-25-2005, 01:26 PM
I finished the new Harry Potter and let me tell you it was quite depressing. If you are a harry potter fan then you will agree that the death of dumbledore is monumentously a let down. And to top it off, harry debates wether or not he will come back to Hogwarts?! I have been recently comparing this the Empire Strikes Back from Star Wars. As nerdy as Star Wars and Harry Potter may sound in the same sentence from a 20 year old :? , it still is heartbreaking to have the series end on a note like this. Now We have to wait who knows how long for the next book to come out. I just finished yesterday and now Im hoping for the new one to come out next week! Its killing me.

I also finished it yesterday and would like the next one to come out tomorrow :wink: And I was also very disappointed that Dumbledore died :( and I don't think JK Rowling had to kill him because of the actor being dead, the movie doesn't dictate her the books ...
I wonder how everything will finish ? She already said that Harry Potter could die as well as Voldemore ...
Anyway it is going darker and darker ...

evoWalo
07-25-2005, 01:43 PM
I'm not surprised it is getting darker and darker. The readership is getting older and older. ;)

pharzo
07-25-2005, 04:19 PM
JK had to Kill Dumbledor. The original actor's dead and was replaced by Sir Michael Gambo who appeared as the "celebrity in the reasonably priced car" on BBC Top Gear last December 8, 2002.

Dude...what are you on???

The actors were already replaced for the third movie...why would she kill him off in the 6th book??

This book, by itself, is definitely the worst one so far. But that's because it's basically part 1 of the 7th book...this one is a prelude. Less of an independent book than the other ones.

evoWalo
07-26-2005, 01:39 PM
JK had to Kill Dumbledor. The original actor's dead and was replaced by Sir Michael Gambo who appeared as the "celebrity in the reasonably priced car" on BBC Top Gear last December 8, 2002.

Dude...what are you on???

The actors were already replaced for the third movie...why would she kill him off in the 6th book??

This book, by itself, is definitely the worst one so far. But that's because it's basically part 1 of the 7th book...this one is a prelude. Less of an independent book than the other ones.
Just speculating on why Dumbledor was killed. The book I think was being written when the actor died.

pharzo
07-26-2005, 02:37 PM
Sorry, but that's a little...out there...

The plot was set 7 years ago when the first book was out. We don't yet know why Dumbledore was killed, but it's a part of the larger plot that will be outlined in the final book. She would not drastically change the plot because an actor died